English version of one in a million

The australian singer Victoria S made a cover of Yamashita Tomohisa's 'One in a million'
She did the cover four months after Yamapi's single. Yamapi's 'One in a Million' had a lot of English in the lyrics but this version is completely written in English
However Yamapi scored a #1 hit, while her best rankings were the 45th and 49th place in the Austrian and German charts.

I'm totally Yamapi-addicted and reeally can't appreciate this version. The singing is bad and too much autotuned. Only the chorus is good, but that's because it's tthe same. The other verses are bad.

What do you think
Which one is better???

Xx